Misleading Disclosures: SEC Enforcement is Watching…Everything
Enforcement Division Director Stephanie Avakian recently gave a speech to recap actions over the past three years (also see the speech from SEC Chair Jay Clayton). The walk down memory lane touched on these headline-grabbing allegations:
– Fraudulent accounting practices intended to misrepresent a company’s underlying financial condition, as in the Commission’s actions against Theranos, Hertz, and Penn West and their former executives
– Intentionally distorted non-GAAP metrics and key performance indicators, as in the Commission’s actions against Wells Fargo, Fiat Chrysler, Valeant, and Walgreens
– Misrepresentations or omissions in connection with risk factors, as in the Commission’s actions against Facebook and Mylan
– Materially misleading and incomplete disclosures, as in the Commission’s actions against Nissan and Volkswagen and their former executives
Stephanie acknowledged that the Division’s focus on financial fraud isn’t new — but she emphasized the expansion of the types of info that Enforcement is tracking. If her remarks had a theme song, it would be Rockwell’s “Somebody’s Watching Me” — and it’s a reminder to companies to watch all forms of disclosure. Here’s an excerpt:
Our focus on financial fraud and issuer disclosure cases resulted in some significant changes in how we approach identifying and investigating potential misconduct. Our proactive efforts to identify cases has employed a variety of research, approaches, internal and external tools, and other information sets. We routinely look at all public information about an issuer – statements made by a company or its officers, in filings, during investor presentations, in tweets or blog posts; related commentary by others including analysts, shorts, competitors, shareholders – to develop a deep understanding of the company’s reporting environment and industry. This is not a low cost investment, but it has provided substantial value in identifying potential financial fraud.
Further, in appropriate cases, we are employing strategies to streamline these investigations in an effort to substantially accelerate the pace of our investigations. This has come through a purposeful effort by our investigative teams to efficiently triage issues, increase staffing, make more targeted requests at the outset, substantively engage early with relevant parties, and leverage cooperation. We have already seen some success in our acceleration efforts and expect to see those successes continue in the near and long term.
This recap actually occurred before the flurry of enforcement activity that we saw a couple of weeks ago — so you can add those settlements to the tally. Also see the Davis Polk memo — noting that the speech signaled that the SEC may seek increased penalties in future insider trading cases, rather than disgorgement.
-Liz Dunshee, TheCoporateCounsel.net October 14, 2020
Want to keep reading?
Great. Enter your email address and gain instant access to this article